Digital immigrants
"Is Google Making Us Stupid?"
June 17, 2008 Filed in: The real
world |
Ideas
So asks Nicholas Carr in the cover article of the
July/August Atlantic Monthly.
I put this here not just because i't's an
interesting and worthy read, but because it
resonates with me, both the good and the bad. The
good is how the technology has quite fundamentally
changed my ability to write: I simply couldn't do
what I do with pen and paper, though like many, I
still like to print out an intermediate draft now
and then to read through end-to-end (but that may
be simply a lack of the right technology to enable
the same ability). The bad is that I, too, have
slowly, over a decade, gone from voracious book
reader to being barely able to keep up with print
publications like the Economist and
Atlantic Monthly. Perhaps the
glass-is-half-full explanation is just that my
information consumption has actually gone up; it's
just different. The article's mention of
neurological rewiring echos Marc Prensky's thought
in Digital natives, digital
immigrants part 2.
On the other hand, I can't say I resonate with the glass-is-half-empty predictions of the article. Change of the sort described just is. If indeed it's a problem - and I don't think so - then the genie is already out of the bottle and all we can do is manage the effects. Wired Magazine's cover article The End of Science and two related articles, Tap Into the 12-Million-Teraflop Handheld Megacomputer and Supercomputing Power Hits the Desktop, Minus the Software, curiously speak in some way to this issue from a different perspective.
On the other hand, I can't say I resonate with the glass-is-half-empty predictions of the article. Change of the sort described just is. If indeed it's a problem - and I don't think so - then the genie is already out of the bottle and all we can do is manage the effects. Wired Magazine's cover article The End of Science and two related articles, Tap Into the 12-Million-Teraflop Handheld Megacomputer and Supercomputing Power Hits the Desktop, Minus the Software, curiously speak in some way to this issue from a different perspective.
Digital disorder vs the Luddite
July 10, 2007 Filed in: The real
world
They've gone head-to-head on this now: an
interesting representation of the "Wikipedia vs
Britannica" debate.
David Weinberer is author of Everything is Miscellaneous: The Power of the New Digital Disorder. "We're very good at organizing things in the real world ... But ... we always have to follow two basic principles: Everything has to go somewhere, and no thing can be in more than one place. That's just how reality works. But in the digital world we're freed from those restrictions."
Andrew Keen is author of The Cult of the Amateur: How today's Internet is killing our culture and, as you'll see, says himself he is "a disgraceful fascist luddite communist control freak monarchist failed dotcom entrepreneur".
David Weinberer is author of Everything is Miscellaneous: The Power of the New Digital Disorder. "We're very good at organizing things in the real world ... But ... we always have to follow two basic principles: Everything has to go somewhere, and no thing can be in more than one place. That's just how reality works. But in the digital world we're freed from those restrictions."
Andrew Keen is author of The Cult of the Amateur: How today's Internet is killing our culture and, as you'll see, says himself he is "a disgraceful fascist luddite communist control freak monarchist failed dotcom entrepreneur".
Digital natives, digital immigrants
March 25, 2007 Filed in: Cyberspace
2.0 |
Ideas
An absolute classic must-read: Digital Natives, Digital
Immigrants by Marc Prensky. “It is amazing
to me how in all the hoopla and debate these
days about the decline of education in the US we
ignore the most fundamental of its causes. Our
students have changed radically. Today’s
students are no longer the people our
educational system was designed to teach.”